tv Sanjay Gupta MD CNN June 11, 2011 4:30am-5:00am PDT
say eight people who are injured in last month's tornado in joplin have contracted a rare type of fungus. three have died. one of the deaths directly linked to the infection which can occur when dirt becomes lodged under the skip skin. anyone hurt while in the tornado zone should get prompt medical attention. i'll be back at the top of the hour with more live news. time for the good doctor. our investigation of cell phone safety in a possible link to cancer. it's triggered a lot of questions. i'm going to answer as many as i can this morning. also a neuro scientist who is literally peeling back your subconscious. put it this way, you don't have as much control over yourself as you think you do. we'll explain. a top race car driver beating diabetes with the help of his dad and a little ingenuity. a family loses a beloved sister and then discovers it was
suicide. and then they realize someone else helped her do it. we're going to hear from them in a moment and from the man who some people are calling the new dr. death. the original dr. death, of course, was dr. jack kevorkian who died last week of natural illness at the age of 83. he revealed a pretty grim view of life in general. >> said it nicely, what crime has this child committed that it should be born? >> that's a profound -- it's a deeply pessimistic thing to hear. >> it's very sensible. >> according to a gallup poll, americans are spritz down the middle, as to whether assisted suicide is morally okay. while the public is evenly divided only two states, organ and washington, have laws allowing doctors or anyone else for that matter to assist in suicide and even then, only under some circumstances. more than 40 states explicitly forbid it and yet it happens more than you might think.
jana had a long history of mental illness and when she was 58, she took her life. according to the final exit network, she is one of hundreds they have helped along to a peaceful death. vicky doesn't see it that way. >> i think jana would be here if final exit had not been involved. >> reporter: jana submitted her application to final exit. at the time dr. eggbert was the group's medical director and determined jana was ready to die. >> they had what she sent them which said odd things about her health. it said liver cancer and what else did it say? >> rat poison. >> yes. >> and all sorts of real strange things. >> reporter: one day in march of 2007, vicky received a suspicious call asking them to check on jana. >> a day or two later we did go over to check on jana because we
weren't able to reach her by phone and we found her dead. >> reporter: she died by suffocating herself with a tank of helium. it's final exit's method of choice. >> their theory is that they don't want to be part of any physical activities with the person that's going to die, so they explain how to do it. show them how to open the valves and have them do the valves themselves. >> reporter: ultimately eggbert, along with three final exit members were tried with conspiracy to commit manslaughter. two members entered plea agreements and because of a hung jury, the third will be retried. as for eggbert, the jury found him not guilty. >> you remember where this was? >> reporter: for the thomass, there are only pictures left. >> everybody's all dressed. look at jana, she looks great. and the doctor tried but acquitted in jana's case, joins me now from baltimore. thanks for joining us, doctor. you know, some folks have taken to calling you the new dr.
death. i know that's not a term that sits well with you. the starting point, how would you explain what you do? >> i explain it very simply by saying it's something that somebody desperately wants to have happen. there are a lot of people who are suffering, there are a lot of people who have suffered, and have come to the point where they can't handle it anymore so they want out. >> you don't like the term suicide, even, i understand. why not? >> well, suicide has a lot of negative connotations, especially from a religious point of view, and so basically the reason we try and use the word like hastening death, for example, the -- is because of the stigma associated with it. you know, just a few years ago, this was illegal. a supreme court judge said it's immoral right now, so that the idea, there's a very powerful
people who are very uncomfortable with the idea from a religious point of view. >> you're referring to justice scalia, suicide, referring to it as immoral. want to ask you about jana's case, now that the trial is over you can talk about this. the family says they were never contacted or consulted. they said also she suffered from a history of mental illness. was she of sound mind to even consider this idea of ending her own life? >> well, was she of sound mind? we thought so. she was sufficiently sound to get along in society. she had friends, she had a car, she kept a lovely house, she was a person who officially is of sound enough mind to get along in society. she's not incarcerated. she has had mental therapy. so we were considering her of a sound mind. >> during your tenure with the final exit network, how many applications did you review and
how many did you actually approve? >> well, in the four or five years roughly, i don't -- i didn't keep a tally of the numbers, so that the president of the organization, dr. denson, would be a better source. i would guess around 300 patients, people that applied for this service. >> and can you give a percentage? if someone applies, how likely are they to be approved? >> well into the 90%. >> most people. >> everybody -- >> pardon? >> most people get approved. what criteria are you considering when you look at one of these applications and does someone have to be terminal, does someone have to be physically suffering? how do you measure that? >> people invariably are suffering. mostly it's physical, a lot of it is psychological, a lot of it -- of the people that i talked with and the people that i met, and the people that i
read about, all of them have been suffering not just a while, but for a long while. >> when you're actually seeing someone die, because of your decision, what is that like for you as a doctor? >> well, i never got used to it. i was telling someone sometime, a psychologist, i just don't seem to get used to this and she chuckled and laughed at me and said when you get used to it, that's the time you ought to quit. >> it's a fascinating discussion, a polarizing one, as you better than anyone knows, but i appreciate you spending time with us. >> sure. my report on redcation from cell phones and a possible link to cancer. a lot of people talking about this. you have questions. i'm going to try to answer more of them, straight ahead. its quality and performance, and making their factories more environmentally friendly. producing products that save on fuel and emissions, and some that can be reused again. ♪
and promoting eco-friendly and safety driving campaigns. ♪ one team. one planet. bridgestone. a network of possibilities. in here, the planned combination of at&t and t-mobile would deliver our next generation mobile broadband experience to 55 million more americans, many in small towns and rural communities, giving them a new choice. we'll deliver better service, with thousands of new cell sites... for greater access to all the things you want, whenever you want them. it's the at&t network... and what's possible in here is almost impossible to say. 8% every 10 years.age 40, we can start losing muscle -- it's the at&t network... wow. wow. but you can help fight muscle loss with exercise and ensure muscle health. i've got revigor. what's revigor? it's the amino acid metabolite, hmb to help rebuild muscle and strength naturally lost over time.
[ female announcer ] ensure muscle health has revigor and protein to help protect, preserve, and promote muscle health. keeps you from getting soft. [ major nutrition ] ensure. nutrition in charge! at 190 miles per hour, the wind will literally lift ordinary windshield wipers off the glass. so, did we build a slower car? or design wipers that could handle anything? what do you think? the cadillac cts-v, the world's fastest production sedan. we don't just make luxury cars, we make cadillacs
a federal judge struck down a key requirement that everyone buy insurance coverage if they weren't already covered. through an employer, medicaid or medicare. that judge's ruling is on hold while the case is appealed. that requirement, like a lot of the law, doesn't go into effect until 2014. but according to a new cnn opinion research poll, it's already unpopular. 44% for it, 54% against. in that same poll after the economy, people said health care is the most important issue in their vote for president. so joining me now from new york to talk about this, cnn's senior legal analyst jeffrey toobin. thanks for joining us, jeff. >> hi, sanjay. >> so jeff, we've talked about this before, but what happened in this hearing here? did the judges sound like they would support the law or throw it out like the judge in the first trial? >> well, you know, this one was a little hard to tell. just to put this all in a little perspective, there have been a lot of these cases all over the country, kicking around the federal courts.
so far, three district court judges have upheld the law, said it's constitutional, two district court judges have said it's unconstitutional, including the one in florida. >> right. >> and these cases are starting to move through the appeals process. this summer there are four federal appeal courts hearing these appeals. one was heard about a month ago. the one was this week in atlanta. the first one that was heard, sounded like the judges were pretty sympathetic to the constitutionality of the law. this one i think it was more ambiguous. but it's always hard to read from judges questions how they're ultimately going to vote in the case. i don't think we can say anything conclusive at this point. >> let's put a little bit of specifics on what we're talking about here. the law is this grand bargain, a safety net, insurance companies required to cover anyone, even if they have a serious or chronic illness. the tradeoff is you have to carry insurance. you can't just wait until you get sick.
if the judge throws out the insurance buying requirement, this mandate so to speak, what happens to the rest of the deal? >> that's very hard to say. and, in fact, that's one of the key arguments even in both sides, because the anti-health care law advocates say look, this part of the law is so integral to the whole system, that you have to throw out the whole thing. and one of the judges, in fact, did that. all the other judges have said you can separate this. but as a political matter, if you get rid of the mandate, and don't wind up forcing all those millions of new people into the system, there is a sort of political question of how it's going to work because all other parts of the law, like the part that says kids can stay on their parents' insurance until they're 25, the part that says you can't be denied insurance because of a
preexisting condition, those benefits are more or less contingent on getting all those new customers into the insurance system. so it's very hard to know how to work. by the way, let's be clear, it's not at all clear that the supreme court, which almost certainly will get this case, will strike down any part of this law. the last word is a long way away. >> thanks a lot. appreciate your time. another story back in the headlines this week as well, cell phones and cancer. we've been covering this for some time. we're continuing to ask the question, is your cell phone safe? you know in the past, the world health organization has said there's no way cell phones can be problematic. problem is, they don't say that any more. they say cell phones are possibly carcinogenic, to say they could cause cancer. earlier this week i sat down with ryan seacrest on his radio show, he asked me to come on and asked me if parents should postpone getting their kids a cell phone? >> i'm delaying getting my kids
cell phones, in part because of this and in part because, you know, i just think they spend more time on a device that has all sorts of games and other things on it, which i think is another issue, but i also think we, you know, these types of problems that we're talking about, potential brain cancers, take 20 to 30 years to develop. there's only been cell phones really in popularity in this country over the last 15 years. our kids will use them their entire life. >> the scale and exposure is what's going to be exponentially different from our kids compared to us. it's not just ryan seacrest asking these questions. my e-mail, my twitter, we've been flooded with lots of messages from all of you viewers looking for advice. i wanted to say, really all boils down to this. as silly as it sounds try to keep your cell phone away from your body as much as possible. use your speakerphone when you can, a corded earpiece or text to keep your phone away from your head and out of your pocket. protecting your brain from
aflac! oh, i've just got major medical... major medical. ...but it helps pay the doctors. pays the doctors, boyyy! [ quack ] oh yeah? what about your family? ♪ we added aflac, so we get cash! it's like our safety net... ♪ to help with the mortgage or whatever we need! so my family doesn't feel the pain too. ha! [ male announcer ] help protect your family at aflac.com. [ pigeons ] heyyy! hooo!!! >> announcer: this past year alone there's been a 67% spike in companies embracing the cloud-- big clouds, small ones, public, private, even hybrid. your data and apps must move easily and securely to reach many clouds, not just one. that's why the network that connects, protects, and lets your data move fearlessly through the clouds means more than ever.
. most of us want to know why we do what we do. sure we know our decisions are made in the brain but research is shedding light on how many of those decisions are made at the subconscious level, more so than you think. dr. david eagleman is author of the new book "incognito" the secret lives of the brain." great title. >> thanks. essentially so much going on, so much hidden machinery under the hood there, and it's starting to fascinate me to realize how much that goes on that we have no awareness of.
>> is this something you can study? when you think about subconscious level decision making, how do you start even thinking about that? >> well, here's the simplest example. when you move your arm or something it feels like it's effortless. you and i know there's a lightning storm of neural activity that underpins that. and if it weren't for the fact that we were a neuroscience, we wouldn't even suspect the existence of cells and muscles and electrical signals, right? it turns out everything in our lives is like that. there are lots of examples of this. for example, i was impressed by a study i saw many years ago when i first got into neuro science, men were asked to rate the attractiveness of women's faces and photographs. in half the photos the women's eyes had been dilated. the men uniformly found these photographs were more attractive but none were able to say i noticed her pupil was a millimeter wider here. but their brains knew. dilated eyes is a sign of sexual
readiness in women. brains gave them the appropriate signals more attracted over here, behavior was steered appropriately, even though they had no idea why. turns out most of our attractions and desires is like that. >> you had another experiment i think as well where you have people actually do something to give them an idea of how their subconscious mind is thinking, mimicking motions. >> i was going to ask you to do this. so put your hands on the steering wheel. >> okay. >> and i would like you to make a lane change into your left lane. driving and you want to move over into the left lane. >> to the left lane. >> uh-huh. >> okay. >> so like almost everyone else, you got it wrong. so it turns out that the way you make a lane change in the left lane, you go to the left, back to center and all the way just as far to the right and then you -- what you did, just steered you off on to the sidewalk. >> and then turn far enough to the right. >> the point is, there are many things your brain takes care of, almost everything in your life your brain takes care of and we don't have conscious access to most of it. most of what you can do you
don't even know how you're doing it. when you recognize the way your father walks or the sound of somebody's voice or things like that, your conscious brain doesn't even have access to it. what happens is, your conscious mind is like a little stowaway on a transatlantic steam ship and is taking credit for the whole thing and it's not giving credit to the massive engineering that's under foot. >> what does someone do with this? i guess if it's at the subconscious level that's where it's relegated. is there a lesson here? >> yes. it turns your brain is like a team of rivals always battling it out. the important thing for us trying to understand ourselves, is how do we negotiate with ourselves to manage this? we all have short-term temptations, whatever it is in our own lives, and what we have to think hard about is how do you set up these structures so that the long-term decision making can win? for example, alcoholics who are trying to quit, need to get rid of all the alcohol in their house. or, people who are trying to lose weight can go to these websites where you give, let's
say, $100 to total strangers and you say, i promise that i'm going to lose 10 pounds by this date and if i don't you keep the money. >> wow. >> otherwise i get the money back. your present self is giving away money so your future self has to work hard to get it back. that's the way we can tip the battle between the short and long-term parts of our brain. >> you mentioned alcohol a couple times, alcohol in the sense it could make you less likely to exercise the conscious good judgment. are there things that can act in the opposite way, medications or anything else that you found that can enhance your ability to let the team of rivals on your side win? >> i mean, really it's just this issue of being part of the community fabric. i think having the right sort of community around you, is what gives you that. >> surrounding yourself with peers whose values you emulate. >> quite right. >> fascinating guy. so young. i expected you to be older for all that you've done. >> i eat my spinach and broccoli. >> good stuff. still ahead, a truly inspiring story about overcoming life's
took some wild risks when i was young. but i was still taking a risk with my cholesterol. anyone with high cholesterol may be at increased risk of heart attack. diet and exercise weren't enough for me. i stopped kidding myself. i've been eating healthier, exercising more, and now i'm also taking lipitor. if you've been kidding yourself about high cholesterol, stop. along with diet, lipitor has been shown to lower bad cholesterol 39 to 60 percent. lipitor is fda approved to reduce the risk of heart attack and stroke in patients who have heart disease or risk factors for heart disease. [ female announcer ] lipitor is not for everyone, including people with liver problems and women who are nursing, pregnant or may become pregnant. you need simple blood tests to check for liver problems. tell your doctor if you are taking other medications or if you have any muscle pain or weakness. this may be a sign of a rare but serious side effect. lets go... haha. if you have high cholesterol, you may be at increased risk of heart attack and stroke.
don't kid yourself. talk to your doctor about your risk and about lipitor. [ female announcer ] wake up to sweetness with honey nut cheerios cereal. kissed with real honey. and the 100% natural whole grain oats can help lower your cholesterol. you are so sweet to me. bee happy. bee healthy. you know we like to think professional athletes have it made. they're young, healthy, seemingly invulnerable. after this story you might think twice. this saturday night, indy car race at the texas motor speedway in car number 83, there's a driver who went through some serious twists and turns before
he even made it to the starting line. >> the 83 of charlie kimble. >> growing up i wanted to race professionally. i wanted to race in the indianapolis 500. >> he is 10.9 seconds behind the race leader. >> reporter: this year, charlie kimball finally fulfilled his dream. in order to get here, though, he had to overcome a big hurdle. you see four years ago he was told he had diabetes. so kimball took time to figure out how to cope with his diagnosis and figure out if he could race with diabetes. something indy car officials say was a first. to qualify for these races he not only had to be fast, he had to be healthy. >> if i go too high my reaction times slow and i'm not competitive. if i go too low i get lightheaded, go low enough i could pass out and cause an accident. >> reporter: his diabetes led him to a sponsor. kimball's pit crew consists of mechanics, engineers, and his
doctor. he has to make sure his body is ready along with his car, which now has special equipment. >> i wear a continuous glucose monitor, which is a sensor i have on my body and it reads blood glucose, wirelessly transmits to a pager-like display i velcro to the steering wheel. >> reporter: he has a backup system designed by his father, just in case. >> i've got a drink bottle mounted in the car. fill it with orange juice which is full of sugar. the tube runs into my helmet and white house having to take my hands off the steering wheel i can bring my sugars up and don't have to stop. >> reporter: he's determined to get the message out that diabetes doesn't have to stand in the way of your dreams. >> i'm living proof that you can do almost anything you want in life with diabetes. even drive a race car at a couple hundred miles an hour. >> great stories of people overcoming